Wright Ave Tops Hefty HDC Agenda Tonight (Wed, May 8)

Another view shows a roof style that critics object is not typical of old Portsmouth

A drawing of Wright Ave shows a French-style mansard roof that critics say doesn’t fit in with that end of State St

The development known colloquially as “Wright Ave”  leads a heavy Historic District Commission agenda tonight, and folks who are concerned about the authenticity of the city’s fragile vintage appearance are hoping for a strong turnout.

Some critics feel the development proposal known as "Wright Ave" has a style too uncommon in Portsmouth for a gateway to the city. Other people say it's too big and that it should be clearly shown in all depictions, not hidden by trees

Some critics feel the development project known as “Wright Ave” has the wrong style for a gateway to the city. Others say it’s too bulky and should be clearly shown in all depictions, not hidden by trees

 

State Street viewed from the Rusty Hammer

State Street viewed from the Rusty Hammer

 

A view of the Wright Ave project as shown in city websiteA view of the Wright Ave project as seen on city website

The project at 67-77 State Street has caused consternation among some residents who feel it is too big and the wrong style for a gateway to Portsmouth from Memorial Bridge and Maine.

For example, Joyce Volk, an architectural historian who lives in the South End a few blocks from the proposed development, walked the downtown historic business district yesterday morning, from Court Street to Bow Street and Marcy Street to Market Square.

“From Pleasant Street down to the river, there is one mansard roof,” she noted, referring to a French-style roof in vogue during the Second Empire of Napoleon III. “That’s a late 19th century addition to the Rusty Hammer. Most buildings from Pleasant Street east are three stories, some four, and if four, often with dormers in a pitched or hip roof.”

“The proposed Wright Avenue building has fortunately been reduced from five stories to four, but still has the mansard roof and all those projections and recessions in the walls which are entirely out of character with its neighbors,” Volk goes on.

“The surrounding buildings… are largely early Federal in style, with flat brick walls, an occasional rounded corner, and windows with white frames. Surely a good and serviceable modern structure can be in this style and not try to revive a late 19th century style that is exceedingly rare anywhere in downtown Portsmouth.“

The end of Ceres Street as it will look if the HDC approves this version of the development project

The end of Ceres Street with 173-175 Market St project as last shown

Also coming up for an HDC work session is the large addition proposed at 173-175 Market Street catty-corner from the Moffatt-Ladd House:

Another HDC work session will focus on a large development proposed for 111 Maplewood Ave.:

The HDC is slated to consider this project for 111 Maplewood Ave in May

One of the latest views available view of 111 Maplewood Ave project

Yet another will focus on 275 Islington Street.

A view of 275 Islington project from plans at City Hall

A view of 275 Islington project, from plans at City Hall

“I think we have to get the height of these buildings down,” said Volk.

“Within the Historic District, they should not be over four stories because that’s what most of them are that are part of the Historic District.”

 

 

1 thought on “Wright Ave Tops Hefty HDC Agenda Tonight (Wed, May 8)

  1. Christa

    Hello there! I could have sworn I’ve been to this blog before but after reading through some of the post I realized it’s new to me.
    Anyways, I’m definitely happy I found it and I’ll be book-marking and checking back frequently!

    Feel free to surf to my blog post … explanation, Christa,

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *